Untucking My Sheet Saga…
Searching for the perfect bedding has been like waiting for rain in a drought…useless and disappointing. I have had several different sheet sets in my life, but I’ve struggled with the same problem time and time again: affordable sheet sets ($100 or less) frequently pill, tear, fade, and stretch. This is why I’m wary of rolling the dice on low-quality products. On the other hand, I’m also tired of looking at premium bedding brands online, only to find the prices are insanely expensive. No one wants to spend $200-$300 on a sheet set. So where’s the happy medium?
I am constantly on the hunt for the best materials, most durability, and aesthetic colors. As a product reviewer at heart, I most recently tried Buffy’s Cloud Sheet Set and Target’s Casaluna Sheet Set, and when I say I think I found my holy grail, I mean it. I’m going to walk you through everything you need to know about these sheet sets so you can decide which is worth the investment, but only one of them gets my stamp of approval.
The Low Down–Which Sheet Set Should You Invest In?
Let’s dive right in. When it comes to choosing the perfect set of sheets, I like to consider all the specs that set them apart and of course, the price tag. (All features outlined below are based on Queen sizes).
Features & Value for Money: Buffy
After taking a closer look at what makes Buffy’s Cloud Sheet Set special, I get what all the buzz is about. Buffy made a 100% long-staple cotton sheet set in partnership with Better Cotton™ that’s extra durable with the softness and comfort the brand is known for. While it may seem a bit pricey at $125, it includes 2 pillowcases, 1 fitted sheet, and 1 flat sheet in a standard queen size. In my opinion, you’re getting superior quality for a reasonable price. What’s even better: there’s a sale for 20% off going on right now.
On the other hand we have Casaluna’s 300 Count Solid Sheet Set. These sheets are made from a blend of 62% cotton and 38% polyester, coming in at a more budget-friendly $85 for the same combo of 2 pillowcases, 1 fitted sheet, and 1 flat sheet. But here’s the kicker–not all cottons are equal. Many brands advertise a high thread count or tout the origin of their cotton, but the key difference is in the length of the fiber. The longer fibers in Buffy’s long-staple cotton make for higher quality, softer, and stronger bedding—that’s also more absorbent and breathable than a combination of materials.
In the long run, coughing up the extra cash with Buffy’s 100% cotton sheets will save you from buying a whole new sheet set later, as they will surely outlast Target’s Casaluna line.
Durability: Buffy
Everyone wants to invest in sheets that’ll last years, but the sad truth is most brands don’t actually deliver on that promise—except Buffy. The Cloud Sheet Set is just built stronger. Buffy uses extra long-staple cotton and goes the extra mile to enhance it by ring-spinning their yarn for maximum durability. To ensure their sheets last a lifetime, Buffy relies on pure data. Their 100% cotton sheets are third-party lab tested using the industry’s most advanced and rigorous methods including:
- Random Tumble Pilling Testing (tests for fabric pilling): Buffy’s Cloud Sheets scored in the 99th percentile. If that’s not top-class quality, I don’t know what is.
- Martindale Pressure Testing (tests for wear): Scoring in the 97th percentile, Buffy is one of the few that makes it to this level. I can vouch that after owning their cotton sheets for quite some time now, they’re as good as new.
- Breaking Strength Grab Testing (tests for tearing): Buffy scored in the 98th percentile but I’m not surprised. I can tell just by touching these sheets how strong and sturdy they are. The best part: they’re still smooth to the touch and feel silky soft against your skin.
- Laundrometer Testing (tests for resilience): Washing and drying can take a toll on your sheets. But with Buffy, you don’t have to worry about having to constantly replace your sheets. Scoring in the 98th percentile, these cotton sheets are engineered to stand the test of time.
The Cloud Sheet Set showed no pilling, tearing, stretching, or color fading for the equivalent of 300 washes and 5+ years of use. Those are some pretty impressive stats, but there’s more. Buffy’s cotton sheets scored in the top 1-3% of all bedding fabrics tested. If you’re looking for the epitome of durability, Buffy’s it.
Colors & Aesthetics: Casaluna
Now, let’s talk about colors. Target’s Casaluna stands out in this category, offering a wider range of fun and neutral colors, including one more than Buffy’s Cloud Sheet Set. Casaluna’s sheets come in Dark Gray, Natural, Rose, White, Light Teal, and Sage Green. While Buffy offers Cream, Neptune (blue), Rain (light gray), Shadow (navy), and White color options.
On a side note: Buffy frequently releases new colors in both their Cotton and Eucalyptus Sheets, so you might find the shade you’re looking for eventually. Personally, I’m in love with my Buffy sheets color choice. I went with Neptune and it looks super bright in person and adds just the right amount of color pop to my bed. Plus, it’s dyed with OEKO-TEX® certified dyes, just like Casaluna, ensuring both brands’ commitment to safe and sustainable practices.
Cooling Capabilities: Buffy
When it comes to staying cool during those scorching summer nights, cotton sheets reign supreme. Cotton’s two biggest strengths are: it’s a natural heat conductor and moisture absorber, meaning it transmits heat well and will cool you down better than any other natural material. Here’s where Buffy shines brightest. With their top-notch materials, Buffy’s sheets offer superior cooling properties, making them perfect for staying comfortable. To top it off, the Cloud Sheet Set is more durable and affordable than most cotton alternatives.
While Casaluna does a decent job, I still found myself waking up in a sweat through the summer heat. You truly can’t go wrong with cotton sheets for coolness, especially if you’re a hot sleeper like me. Buffy knows how to keep cool (it’s their thing)—and after sleeping with the Cloud Set for months, I have to admit they’ve earned their place as an authority on cooling bedding.
The Award For Best Cotton Sheets Goes To…Buffy
The results are in. After thoroughly testing both sheets for quite some time now, I have to admit that while they both offer great qualities, Buffy takes the crown as the clear winner. I can confidently say that I’ve experienced the best sleep of my life, and it’s all thanks to Buffy’s cotton sheets. I’m never going back to another brand. The softness, temperature-regulating properties, durability, and high-quality 100% long-staple cotton you get with Buffy’s Cloud Sheet Set have won me over completely, and simply can’t be beat.
Plus, Buffy has a 50-night trial so you can sleep, wash, dry, and test their sheets for yourself (including free shipping and return fees). This means you can try the Cloud Sheet Set for over 3 months risk-free.
If you want to sleep like royalty with cotton sheets built to last a lifetime, my recommendation is to invest in Buffy’s Cloud Sheets and experience the difference for yourself. Elevate your sleep game with the best of the best in comfort, durability, and coolness—it’s time to make your bed the sanctuary it should be.