The Comforter Showdown
When it comes to the cozy haven of your dreams, nothing is as essential as the perfect comforter. Choosing the right one can make the difference between a restful night’s sleep and endless tossing and turning. To help you find your ultimate sleep partner, we’ve scoured the web, pored over customer reviews, and conducted our own in-depth research to bring you the best of the best. While we could list a dozen or more, we’ll focus on the top 5 comforters online, according to customers.
Whether you’re looking for the epitome of coziness, the most breathable option, or favor non-down options, each of these crowd-favorite comforters has its own unique qualities, but there’s one undisputed champion that wins across every category. Who’s worthy of the title of best overall comforter? With thousands of testimonials that already speak for themselves, we give you the one, the only:
1. Buffy’s Cloud Comforter: The Crème de la Crème of Comforters
Setting the benchmark for coziness, softness, and durability in comforters and duvet inserts, all achieved through innovative and sustainable material choices.
Fill Material: Plant-based down alternative (Eucalyptus TENCEL™ Lyocell)
Shell: Sateen weave TENCEL™ lyocell shell
Price: $175 (Full/Queen) *As of the time of this writing, Buffy’s Cloud Comforter is 20% off, bringing the price down to $140*
Highlights:
- Superior Comfort: Buffy’s Cloud Comforter is made with 100% eucalyptus fibers, which are not only extra fluffy and ultra-soft, but also super breathable. From HGTV to Good Housekeeping and Architectural Digest, The Cloud is constantly at the top of the best comforter hit lists. And with good reason. The Strategist/NY Mag said The Cloud Comforter “Feels like sleeping under a pile of cotton candy,” and we couldn’t agree more.
- Hypoallergenic and Sustainable: Made with TENCEL™ eucalyptus lyocell and a 300 thread count lyocell shell, Buffy’s Cloud absorbs moisture faster than cotton. The Cloud is made entirely of plant-based and recycled materials that are not only soft on your skin, but also on the planet. Each comforter upcycles approximately 50 plastic bottles and is 100% GRS-certified and BPA-free, with a recycled PET fill. Free of harmful chemicals, Buffy’s Cloud Comforter is naturally dyed and safe for pets and kids. Its high-quality materials ensure that The Cloud is designed to endure the everyday wear and tear, and will last a lifetime.
- Temperature Regulating: The Cloud Comforter’s unique design helps you stay cozy in winter and cool in summer. Forget about having to buy different comforters throughout the year, Buffy’s Cloud is the perfect all-season comforter.
- Easy to Clean: A machine-washable comforter? Yes, please! Throw it in the washing machine and tumble dry for a fresh, fluffy feel.
- Customer Love: With a huge fan base, Buffy’s Cloud Comforter is the most reviewed and awarded comforter on the internet. With thousands of raving reviews, customers love Buffy for its luxurious feel, unparalleled comfort, year-round coziness, convenience, price, and sustainability.
Buffy’s Cloud Comforter is the embodiment of comfort, quality, and sustainability. Say goodbye to night sweats and allergies while enjoying the feel of a cloud wrapping around you as you slumber. While other comforters may offer plushness and warmth, few match Buffy’s dedication to the environment and your well-being. Plus, they offer a free 7-night trial (and free returns-50 night policy) that lets you experience Buffy before buying with a temporary hold on your card.
2. Utopia Bedding Comforter Duvet Insert: Most Popular Comforter on Amazon
Utopia’s Duvet Insert is arguably one of Amazon’s most popular comforters, with 110K+ customer ratings, and a 4.6-star rating. Thanks to the array of 13 different colors and patterns this duvet insert comes in, some customers even argue there’s no need for a duvet cover. However, its polyester shell doesn’t make it a sustainable or durable option.
Fill Material: Down alternative (siliconized fiber)
Shell: Polyester
Price: $41.00 (Queen)
Highlights:
- Budget-Friendly: Utopia Bedding’s Comforter is one of the most affordable comforters out there, starting at just $28.99 for the Twin size. Not to mention, it’s regularly on sale. According to thousands of customer reviews, this duvet insert is affordable without skimping on quality. One customer mentions, “Its siliconized fiber filling creates the perfect weight, soft to the touch, not too hot, looks great on the bed.”
- Box-Stitch Design: Keeps the fill in place, preventing clumping.
- Machine-washable: This comforter brings all the convenience to your home. Machine wash in the gentle cycle with cold water, line dry or tumble dry on low heat only.
- Hypoallergenic: While we’re not thrilled about how harmful its siliconized fiber fill is for the environment, this synthetic material has mites and bacteria-repellent properties and is therefore considered antibacterial and hypoallergenic.
If you’re looking for comfort on a budget, Utopia Bedding’s Comforter Duvet Insert is a good choice. It may not have all the bells and whistles of our top pick, but it’s a great value for the price.
3. Egyptian Bedding Siberian Goose Down Comforter: Best Down Comforter on Amazon
If you’re looking for a premium down comforter that checks all the boxes, this might be it. More than 6,500 Amazon customer reviews suggest that this comforter is exceptionally plush, and brings you the fluffiest, puffiest sleeping experience. This is definitely not the best option for environmentally-conscious consumers or anyone looking for an animal feather-free option.
Fill Material: Goose Down
Shell: Cotton
Price: $129.95 (Queen, King, California King)
Highlights:
- The Peak of Luxury: Siberian goose down offers warmth and fluffiness. Customers praise this down comforter as soft, fluffy, warm, breathable, and noiseless. Made from 80% down fiber and 20% waterfowl feather fiber, the Down Comforter from Egyptian Cotton Factory Outlet Store is certified by the Responsible Down Standard (RDS).
- Baffle-Box Construction: Prevents the down from shifting and clumping.
- 100% Egyptian Cotton Cover: Ensures durability and breathability. It’s more on the rigid side, but customers say it tends to get softer after every wash.
- Year-Round Comfort: Ideal for cold winters and cool summers—its medium weight makes it a good option for year-round comfort.
For those who crave the utmost luxury and are ready to invest in their sleep, the Egyptian Bedding Siberian Goose Down Comforter is a dream come true. You’ll feel like you’re sleeping in a high-end hotel every night.
4. Linenspa All-Season Down Alternative Quilted Comforter: Steal of a Deal
For just under $35, this best-selling down alternative comforter has more than 124K Amazon reviews. This is the perfect option if you’re shopping for a dorm room comforter or an extra comforter for when the inlaws come to visit. Great to have as a spare, but we wouldn’t sleep with it every night.
Fill Material: Polyester
Shell: Polyester
Price: $34.99 (Queen)
Highlights:
- Affordable Quality: Provides the comfort of down without the high price. Since it’s polyester, you’re getting a really low price, but don’t expect this comforter to deliver the best quality or hold up the same as the others would.
- All-Season Comfort: Suitable for year-round use, although many customers note that they get cold during the winter months. This comes as no surprise—polyester is not a temperature-regulating material whatsoever.
- Machine Washable: Easy to maintain. Be careful with overwashing polyester, as it won’t stand the test of time as other materials would.
- Not a Great Option For Sensitive Skin: Unlike natural fabrics, polyester is a microfiber that doesn’t allow the skin to breathe, trapping heat and moisture, which can cause skin irritations like acne.
Linenspa’s All-Season Down Alternative Comforter is an affordable alternative for those who desire the comfort of down without breaking the bank. Its easy maintenance makes it a practical choice, but for such a low price point, you can’t expect much in terms of comfort and durability.
5. Brooklinen All Season Down Comforter: Luxury At Its Finest
At almost $400, this comforter wins the most expensive contender on the list. And if you’re looking for a King-size comforter, you’ll be shocked to learn that it goes for $500. As for the quality, you’re getting what you pay for.
Fill Material: Down
Shell: Cotton sateen shell
Price: $379 (Queen)
Highlights:
- 700 Fill Power: Offers an extra cozy and warm experience. Worth noting: this may not be the best option for hot sleepers. All the fluff might have you waking up drenched in sweat in the middle of the night.
- Premium Quality: Made from high-quality, recycled Canadian duck and goose down, Brooklinen’s comforter is made in Canada using ethically sourced down cluster fill that meets the Responsible Down Standard (RDS). That said, down will never be a fully sustainable choice.
- 100% Cotton Cover: Silky-smooth long-staple cotton weave fabric that’s soft and durable. Brooklinen’s comforter is unfortunately not machine-washable.
Brooklinen All Season Down Comforter is a higher-end option that comes at a high price, but it offers undeniable qualities that may justify the investment. You’re getting quality and warmth with a plush and luxurious experience. If you’re particular about the source of your down, this comforter is a wise choice. Brooklinen accepts returns or exchanges within 365 days on all products to ensure customer satisfaction.
Buffy’s Cloud Comforter Reigns Supreme
The world of comforters is vast and varied as you can see, but Buffy’s Cloud Comforter stands tall as the pinnacle of comfort, breathability, year-round versatility, sustainability, and customer satisfaction. While all these choices offer different value, Buffy’s price for value simply can’t be beaten. Now we get why The Cloud Comforter is literally everywhere—it does feel exactly like sleeping on a big, fluffy cloud that hugs you just right.
Investing in a quality comforter is an investment in your sleep and well-being. And with Buffy’s 7-night sleep trial, you can try it for free from the comfort of your home—risk-free. If you’re ready to experience ultimate comfort and coziness, give The Cloud a chance. Trust us, you’ll get what all the hype is about on the very first night of sleeping with it.